They Were Friends to Me

Before we dive in, two resources worth bookmarking:

I found out through someone else that a person I considered one of my closer friends had gotten married. Someone I'd worked alongside for five years. Someone I'd had long conversations with about things that mattered. Someone I'd thought about regularly and assumed thought about me the same way. He hadn't invited me, hadn't mentioned it was coming, hadn't sent a message after the fact.

I sat with that for a long time. I replayed our conversations, looking for the moment I'd misread something. I found nothing. I could recall specific things he'd shared with me, from the name of his hometown to a story about his father. A frustration he'd had at work that he'd never told anyone else, or so he'd said. I remembered all of it clearly. The way introverts tend to remember things about people they've decided matter.

I drafted a message several times. Congratulations. Then I deleted it, because what I actually wanted to say was: did I misunderstand what we were? Was I just convenient? Did any of it register the way it registered for me? I never sent any version of it.

What I learned, slowly and uncomfortably, is that I had been a good friend inside my own head. I'd carried the friendship with extraordinary fidelity. I just hadn't noticed that it was mostly living there.

AI is everywhere, but practical, actionable ways to use it are really rare to find.

The Shift fixes this with focus on a single topic per edition. A real problem AI can solve today.

You’ll see real examples, short workflows, and proven prompts that help you work faster, think better, and automate intelligently under 5 minutes a day.

Once you subscribe, you get access to 3,000+ curated AI tools and 1000+ prompts, so nothing stays theoretical.

If you want AI to work for you in real practical ways, not just ideas, you’ll love The Shift.

And right now, 3 subscribers win a free 1-year Claude Pro subscription. One click to enter.

Subscribe to The Shift

There is research on this that is both vindicating and deeply uncomfortable. A study analysing friendship ties across more than 92,000 subjects found that only 34–53% of perceived friendships are actually mutual. In the most cited version of the study, 94% of people expected their feelings to be reciprocated. Only 53% actually were. Nearly everyone overestimates how mutual their friendships are. But for introverts, the gap can be wider, and the landing harder.

At work, the gap is harder to spot because the conditions that create it feel legitimate. Shared pressure, late projects, difficult conversations with nobody else in the room, these create a sense of closeness that feels earned. And for someone who invests selectively and takes that investment seriously, it can take years to realise the person on the other side of that experience filed it differently.

The pattern has a name: the depth trap. Just because a friendship feels intense doesn't mean it's healthy. Just because someone shares something personal with you doesn't mean they're as invested in you as you are in them. For introverts, depth of feeling becomes a signal that something is real. We confuse how deeply we feel a connection with evidence that the connection is equally shared.

The professional cost of this is real and rarely talked about. Over-investing in the wrong work relationships leaves you feeling depleted. It can also quietly isolate you without you understanding why. The energy spent building a one-sided alliance is energy not spent on relationships that would actually have moved your career forward. The colleague who genuinely advocates for you when you're not in the room. The mentor who remembers your ambitions six months later. Those relationships exist. They just require the same quality of attention you've been spending elsewhere.

Introverts build and maintain friendships through self-disclosure and emotional intimacy. We invest through attention, memory, and emotional presence, often before we've confirmed the other person is doing the same.

By the time the asymmetry becomes visible, we've already spent years building a friendship in our heads that the other person was only partially aware of.

What makes this particular grief hard is that there's no event, fight, or clean ending you can point to. Just a slow realisation that something you thought was real wasn't quite what you believed.

And it doesn't only happen in personal friendships. It happens at work, probably more often than we admit. The colleague you stayed late with during a product launch. The manager you trusted with things you didn't say out loud in meetings. The peer who knew your strengths better than anyone, until they got promoted and the dynamic quietly changed. Introverts invest deeply in the people they work alongside. That investment doesn't come with a receipt.

Sometimes it's sudden. A colleague's promotion announced company-wide that you heard about from someone else. A team restructure where everyone was consulted except you. A lunch you weren't included in, involving people you considered your closest allies at work. Suddenly, the architecture of what you thought was there becomes visible for what it was.

Introverts process in long-term memory. Which means every conversation you had now gets revisited through the new information. You look for the moment you missed. You find things that feel obvious in hindsight and wonder how you didn't see them. You are not being paranoid. You are doing exactly what your brain is built to do. It just hurts in a very specific, thorough way.

The strangest part is the silence around it. Because what are you grieving, exactly? Nobody left the company. Nothing ended dramatically. You just found out it wasn't what you thought. When you try to explain the feeling, it sounds smaller than it is. "We just weren't as close as I thought." But you know that isn't the full sentence.

The pattern of always being the one investing more can lead to loneliness and decreased confidence over time. The hardest part is that we rarely recognise it while it's happening. For introverts who invest slowly, carefully, and with great depth, the imbalance often only becomes visible after significant emotional and professional capital has already been spent.

This is the part that lingers longest. Not the grief about that specific person, but the new caution about everyone. If I got that one wrong, what else am I misreading?

The introvert who already thinks carefully before trusting now thinks even longer. And at work, that caution has real consequences. You share less in meetings. You stop investing in colleagues the way you used to. You keep more distance from your manager. You tell yourself it's professionalism. Sometimes it is. Sometimes it's just a wall you built after someone didn't see what you thought they saw in you.

That withdrawal is understandable. It's also costly, because the introverts who thrive professionally are usually the ones who've found at least a handful of people worth investing in deeply. Closing that door entirely is self-protection wearing wisdom's clothes.

The hardest part of this kind of grief is that it's mostly wordless. You carry it around without ever saying it out loud, which means it never really gets processed.

Use ChatGPT to put something into words that you can't quite say to another person yet.

Not to fix it, or to get advice. Just to name it. There's something about seeing it written back in clear sentences that makes the feeling less shapeless.

If writing to yourself feels too exposed, you can start here but don’t let the AI do the feeling for you.

This week, just sit with one honest observation.

You Are Not Cold. You Are Careful

Why are the people who feel the most deeply always the ones accused of caring the least?

I don't think the people who didn't feel what I felt were cruel. Most of them probably didn't know the weight I'd assigned to what we had. They were just living their version of it, which was lighter than mine.

If you've ever found yourself pulling back from colleagues after something like this, becoming harder to reach, more guarded in meetings, slower to trust, I want to name that directly. It makes sense. It's also one of the quieter ways ambitious introverts stall professionally without realising it. Not through lack of skill or ambition, but through a gradual withdrawal from the relationships that would have carried them further.

What I've learned since is to pay less attention to how deeply I feel something, and more to what the other person actually does. Simply as data. Do they remember things? Do they advocate for you when you're not in the room? Do they show up in ways you didn't ask for?

Because introverts feel people deeply, that capacity is real and genuinely rare. The risk isn't feeling too much, but in assuming the other person is living in the same intensity you are, just more quietly. Sometimes they are, and those working relationships become the ones that define your career. Sometimes they aren't, and learning to tell the difference earlier isn't cynicism. It's just paying the same quality of attention outward that you've always paid inward.

Thank you for reading, and for being part of a community where we're allowed to name the griefs that don't have a word yet.

In your corner,
— Steven

P.S. That colleague who always shows up for everyone else but never asks for anything in return? Forward this their way. This one's for them.

P.P.S. Tired of investing deeply in people at work who don't invest back? Download From Invisible to Unforgettable - a FREE guide to making your work seen by the people who actually matter.