When "Are You Okay?" Becomes the Question You Dread Most

Keep these two resources handy:

Some years ago, I sat in a coffee shop on a Saturday morning, catching up on a book I'd been meaning to continue. I was completely absorbed, thinking through a certain paragraph I'd just read. My face was doing whatever it does when I'm processing ideas.

A woman at the next table leaned over. "Are you okay? You look like you've just had some upsetting news."

I wasn't upset. I was thinking about a concept introduced in the book.

Now I had to put the book down, rearrange my face, and reassure a stranger that I wasn't having a public breakdown. "Oh! No, I'm fine. Just really into this book." Big smile. The whole performance.

She looked relieved. "Oh, good! You just looked so sad. I thought it polite to ask."

I thanked her for checking. Went back to my book. But now I was self-conscious about my face. What expression was I making? Should I smile more while reading? Was my thinking face disturbing other people?

This has happened more than once. The grocery store. Walking down the street. Sitting on a train. My face at rest becomes everyone else's concern. The problem is that I'm the one who has to do the emotional labour of fixing it.

Why does business news feel like it’s written for people who already get it?

Morning Brew changes that.

It’s a free newsletter that breaks down what’s going on in business, finance, and tech — clearly, quickly, and with enough personality to keep things interesting. The result? You don’t just skim headlines. You actually understand what’s going on.

Try it yourself and join over 4 million professionals reading daily.

Check it out

When I'm absorbed in thought, my face goes neutral. For some reason, neutral reads as "something's wrong."

Some faces naturally rest in positions that read as contempt, even when completely relaxed. Your brain processes these cues within 300 milliseconds, forming impressions before either person realises what's happening.

We get so absorbed in thoughts that we forget we have a face. We're a walking brain with no interest in slapping on a fake smile. If you're a quiet person, you know exactly what I mean. Your face in its relaxed state might convey sadness, anger, or judgment when you're actually just comfortable and at peace.

Humans detect face information in 50-75 milliseconds. People are reading your expression faster than you can control it.

I'm not broadcasting anything. I'm just not performing constant contentment. In a culture that expects visible happiness, neutrality gets interpreted as negative.

After the coffee shop incident, I started noticing how often this happens and how much energy it costs.

You're at a dinner party listening to someone tell a story. Thinking about what they're saying. Processing. Then someone across the table catches your eye. "You okay?"

Now you have to stop listening and be cheerful. "Yes! Just really interested in the story." Prove you're having a good time.

This is emotional labour. The regulation of your feelings, the effort it takes to display the appropriate sentiment. Except you're not regulating your feelings. You're regulating other people's anxiety about your face.

I've had strangers tell me to smile on the street. Family members worry I'm depressed when I'm sitting quietly on the couch, deep in thought.

People assume you're not engaged when you're quiet. But quiet people are often more engaged because our brains absorb and find deep meaning in our environment. My quiet isn't sadness. My neutral face isn't upset. I'm just existing without broadcasting emotion every second.

This one taxes the most. People close to you start reading moods that don't exist. Your partner asks what's wrong when nothing is. Your friend thinks they're not welcome when you'd rather just be present without performing. Your parent calls worried because you looked "off" during a video call.

Now you're managing their emotions on top of your own. Reassuring. Explaining. Proving you're fine. Even interactions with loved ones can drain you because of the constant need to be emotionally available. Your face tells a story, whether you realise it or not, but you're not always the author of that story.

I've learned to add smiles I don't feel. To nod more than necessary. To widen my eyes so I look "present."

Not because I'm not present, but because my present face looks wrong to some.
People who recharge through solitude process human faces differently. The brain responds to faces the same way it responds to inanimate objects. You're not wired to constantly broadcast emotions.

But I've learned to fake it anyway. Because the alternative is dealing with "Are you okay?" questions all day.

After the coffee shop incident, I realised I needed a better script. Not a fake smile, just a few honest words that close the conversation without draining me.

Here's a ChatGPT prompt to build yours:

Give it a go? Reply with your favourite.

Pay attention to how much energy you spend managing reactions to your face.

Why you need 48 hours to respond to feedback (and what's actually happening in your brain).

When everyone thinks the conversation is over, but your brain is just getting started.

I've had people ask if I'm okay when I'm sitting peacefully doing nothing. When I'm thinking through a problem that excites me. Sometimes, I get frustrated with correcting that story. From performing cheerfulness to prove I'm fine. From managing other people's discomfort with how my neutral face makes them feel.

I've come to believe that you're not responsible for narrating your inner state to strangers. You're not obligated to smile so people don't worry.

I still add performance smiles in certain contexts. I still explain my "thinking face" to people who matter. But I've stopped apologising for existing with a neutral expression.
The people who stick around learn to read you accurately. And the best part? The energy you get back from not performing can be used for actual thinking instead.

Thank you for reading, for recognising that your face doesn't require a disclaimer, and for being part of a community where we're allowed to exist without broadcasting constant happiness.

Has anyone else experienced this? Reply and tell me your stories.

In your corner,
— Steven

P.S. Share this with the friend who's tired of explaining their face to strangers. They'll feel seen.

P.P.S. Dreading your next networking event? Download the free Networking Scripts for Introverts. 47 pages of templates for LinkedIn messages, email outreach, and conversation starters that skip the small talk. Copy, customise, send.